Page 1 of 1

Belt grinding issue

Posted: Sat May 23, 2020 2:45 am
by alx123
So I changed my clutch set lately as the bearing is starting to make a sound. Bought an aftermarket one instead of the OEM, silly me. The clutch pad that came with the set is not good so I changed it into a much better pads to avoid the clutch shudder problem. With that, the new clutch ran smooth, not a hint of shuddering.

I opened it today to see how the drive parts are doing, and to my surprise, I see dust of black soot everywhere. I know it's my belt being grinded but not sure which part of the new clutch is causing it. Tried running the engine and see how it is but everything seems to be working fine. Smooth, no grinding sound, seems all fine to me.

Checking the belt, it seems fine. I can't even pinpoint which part is being grinded.

Who has any idea what's going on here? Remember, I only changed the clutch set, so the belt is not really new but it's not that old either ( 5k kms).

Should I be worried and buy an OEM clutch set instead?

Maybe I should clean it for now and see how it is after another 100 kms, maybe the belt is just setting in for the new clutch?

Inputs will be appreciated.
Webp.net-resizeimage.jpg
Webp.net-resizeimage.jpg (327.27 KiB) Viewed 1138 times
Webp.net-resizeimage (1).jpg
Webp.net-resizeimage (1).jpg (547.14 KiB) Viewed 1137 times

Re: Belt grinding issue

Posted: Sat May 23, 2020 6:15 am
by mymitzi
Think OEM parts are best.........I'd swap it out.... if it was mine [assembly with bearings already installed] Only about $30.00+ USA.
Should be cheaper in Thailand. Agree the belt looks good but thinking you could get that pretty cheap also.[oem] Good luck.

Re: Belt grinding issue

Posted: Sat May 23, 2020 7:16 am
by alx123
mymitzi wrote:Think OEM parts are best.........I'd swap it out.... if it was mine [assembly with bearings already installed] Only about $30.00+ USA.
Should be cheaper in Thailand. Agree the belt looks good but thinking you could get that pretty cheap also.[oem] Good luck.
Hi, thanks. Yeah, that's what I'm thinking too, replace the clutch set and the belt with OEM.

I decided to open the clutch today and compare it with the original I replaced.

It seem that the OEM has more space to accommodate the belt during higher speed (see photo)
100041759_3299521753414068_8712707932963209216_o.jpg
100041759_3299521753414068_8712707932963209216_o.jpg (100.9 KiB) Viewed 1118 times
below is the aftermarket one im currently using and as you can see there is no sunken space like the OEM one above..

so I'm guessing it's slightly pinching the belt at higher speeds..(you can even see some black soot of rubber in the photo below
99011059_3299520760080834_4522548894231429120_o.jpg
99011059_3299520760080834_4522548894231429120_o.jpg (61 KiB) Viewed 1118 times

My plan now is to either buy a new OEM one or try to swap the bearings between these two and use my old OEM instead.

Let's see what happens as it started to get dark here and I decided to take a break..

Re: Belt grinding issue

Posted: Sat May 23, 2020 1:41 pm
by mymitzi
Swapping the bearings will save you $$ as long as you have the means/tools to install them. Looked again at the price of the
assembly with bearings installed...........a bit over $40.00 [us] Don't forget to add the required grease in the bearings.
Think your plans will solve the issue.

Re: Belt grinding issue

Posted: Sat May 23, 2020 7:03 pm
by Inoplanetyanin
Yes, the belt seems to be wearing at an unhealthy rate if the area was clean when you recently installed it.
I wouldn't know what exactly has changed, but I assume the shape or the distance of the cones... or maybe the stifness of clutch springs.
Whenever aftermarket parts are used in the engine and drive train, there are always unintended consequences. I would not use aftermarket either...

Re: Belt grinding issue

Posted: Sun May 24, 2020 1:19 am
by you you
Aftermarket parts are a bit of a lottery.

At least with OEM it will be of the same quality as the original.

Re: Belt grinding issue

Posted: Sun May 24, 2020 8:58 am
by gn2
alx123 wrote:My plan now is to either buy a new OEM one or try to swap the bearings between these two and use my old OEM instead.
New OEM everything.
Don't attempt to re-use the bearings, you'll probably damage them removing and re-installing.

Re: Belt grinding issue

Posted: Sun May 24, 2020 12:37 pm
by you you
gn2 wrote:
alx123 wrote:My plan now is to either buy a new OEM one or try to swap the bearings between these two and use my old OEM instead.
New OEM everything.
Don't attempt to re-use the bearings, you'll probably damage them removing and re-installing.

This.

Re: Belt grinding issue

Posted: Sun May 24, 2020 12:43 pm
by Gil
"My plan now is to either buy a new OEM one or try to swap the bearings between these two and use my old OEM instead."

You could also just buy the OEM bearings, they are quite cheap.

Re: Belt grinding issue

Posted: Sun May 24, 2020 8:40 pm
by alx123
@Gil

I can't seem to find them anywhere here, the shops sells the driven face instead (see photo). This is better than buying the entire clutch set.
ibfbye.jpg
ibfbye.jpg (95.08 KiB) Viewed 1033 times
@Youyou, Gn2

That seems to be the case. Taking these bearings out seems harder than it looks, especially without the right tools. Iv'e tried and failed, so I don't want to push it harder and damage the bearings as you've said.

I think I should buy a new OEM driven face instead.

Re: Belt grinding issue

Posted: Wed May 27, 2020 6:26 pm
by Old Grinner
Item 8 on parts list . . . less than $40 U.S. plus tax and they ship international just as an FYI. Shipping costs vary of course.

Maybe just consider restoring to OEM as mentioned previously. Item 9 is the movable face.

https://www.bikebandit.com/oem-parts/20 ... #sch939904

Re: Belt grinding issue

Posted: Thu May 28, 2020 10:08 am
by alx123
Update:

My OEM parts arrived today; Movable face(US $31), Belt (US $11).

The OEM face came with a pack of grease and an instruction that says I should put around 6 grams of grease on the bearings and inside the tube using the hole on the sides.
rsz_1rsz_1img20200528173914.jpg
rsz_1rsz_1img20200528173914.jpg (59.14 KiB) Viewed 956 times
rsz_1img20200528174439.jpg
rsz_1img20200528174439.jpg (59.37 KiB) Viewed 956 times
After putting some grease, I immediately installed it and changed the belt. The old belt still looks okay and will serve as my reserve. Now my drive parts are mostly OEM, except for the rollers and the clutch pads (OEM pads suck).

With this I've learned that when it comes to important parts, OEM is the best. I also realized that every time I open my drive parts for cleaning and maintenance,I should also re-grease the bearings.

I've wasted some $ on a bad aftermarket clutch but I've learned how to disassemble and maintain the clutch. I'll take that as a win.

Re: Belt grinding issue

Posted: Thu May 28, 2020 2:54 pm
by iceman
Ebay belts, those sold showing the red Honda label or kevla this or that are rubbish - I ordered one and when it arrived the middle 'white' band was in-even along it's length - some recessed and some sticking out - you can even see that in many of the Ebay photo's! It was even a but longer than it should have been.

Never fitted it, ordered one from a dealer as it was not in stock but next day collection, perfect, no odd bits sticking out and correct size and only £40 compared to £30+delivery for the fake - learnt my lesson there. I wish we could but a Honda original belt for $11 !

The driven face is something you do not want to purchase in the UK off the web or dealers as often it's up to £110+vat! whereas you can purchase it for $30ish + shipping from over-seas (even with that and duty still a lot cheaper)

Re: Belt grinding issue

Posted: Thu May 28, 2020 4:04 pm
by you you
alx123 wrote:Update:

My OEM parts arrived today; Movable face(US $31), Belt (US $11).

The OEM face came with a pack of grease and an instruction that says I should put around 6 grams of grease on the bearings and inside the tube using the hole on the sides.
rsz_1rsz_1img20200528173914.jpg
rsz_1img20200528174439.jpg
After putting some grease, I immediately installed it and changed the belt. The old belt still looks okay and will serve as my reserve. Now my drive parts are mostly OEM, except for the rollers and the clutch pads (OEM pads suck).

With this I've learned that when it comes to important parts, OEM is the best. I also realized that every time I open my drive parts for cleaning and maintenance,I should also re-grease the bearings.

I've wasted some $ on a bad aftermarket clutch but I've learned how to disassemble and maintain the clutch. I'll take that as a win.
All is well that ends well

Re: Belt grinding issue

Posted: Thu May 28, 2020 7:58 pm
by alx123
The tools I used to open the variator and clutch.
rsz_img20200528223116.jpg
rsz_img20200528223116.jpg (87.38 KiB) Viewed 919 times
8mm wrench to remove the cover, torque wrench (size 19mm - 36 lbs torque for clutch, size 22mm-42 lbs torque for the variator), clutch tool, 39mm wrench for the disassembling the clutch.